Learning to Combine Admissible Heuristics Under Bounded Time
نویسندگان
چکیده
Usually, combining admissible heuristics for optimal search (e.g. by using their maximum) requires computing numerous heuristic estimates at each state. In many cases, the cost of computing these heuristic estimates outweighs the benefit in the reduced number of expanded states. If only state expansions are considered, this is a good option. However, if time is of the essence, we can do better than that. We propose a novel method that reduces the cost of combining admissible heuristics for optimal planning, while maintaining its benefits. We first describe a simplified model for deciding which heuristic is best to compute at each state. We then formulate an active learning approach to decide which heuristic to compute at each state, online, during search. The resulting technique, which we call selective max is evaluated empirically, and is shown to outperform each of the individual heuristics that were used, as well as their regular maximum, in terms of number of solved instances and average solution time.
منابع مشابه
Likely-Admissible and Sub-Symbolic Heuristics
It is well-known that while strict admissibility of heuristics in problem solving guarantees the optimality of the A* algorithm, many problems cannot be effectively faced because of the combinatorial explosion. In order to address this problem the notion of 2-admissible search has been introduced, which yields solutions with bounded costs [12]. In this paper, we introduce the related concept of...
متن کاملAdmissible and Minimax Estimator of the Parameter $theta$ in a Binomial $Bin( n ,theta)$ distribution under Squared Log Error Loss Function in a Lower Bounded Parameter Space
Extended Abstract. The study of truncated parameter space in general is of interest for the following reasons: 1.They often occur in practice. In many cases certain parameter values can be excluded from the parameter space. Nearly all problems in practice have a truncated parameter space and it is most impossible to argue in practice that a parameter is not bounded. In truncated parameter...
متن کاملLearning to Search More Efficiently from Experience: A Multi-Heuristic Approach
Learning from experience can significantly improve the performance of search based planners, especially for challenging problems like high-dimensional planning. Experience Graph (E-Graph) is a recently developed framework that encodes experiences, obtained from solving instances in the past, into a single bounded-admissible heuristic, and uses it to guide the search. While the E-Graph approach ...
متن کاملTruncated Linear Minimax Estimator of a Power of the Scale Parameter in a Lower- Bounded Parameter Space
Minimax estimation problems with restricted parameter space reached increasing interest within the last two decades Some authors derived minimax and admissible estimators of bounded parameters under squared error loss and scale invariant squared error loss In some truncated estimation problems the most natural estimator to be considered is the truncated version of a classic...
متن کاملImproving Plan Quality through Heuristics for Guiding and Pruning the Search: A Study Using LAMA
Admissible heuristics are essential for optimal planning in the context of search algorithms like A*, and they can also be used in the context of suboptimal planning in order to find quality-bounded solutions. In satisfacing planning, on the other hand, admissible heuristics are not exploited by the best-first search algorithms of existing planners even when a time window is available for impro...
متن کامل